Huckleberry Labs Turns a 60% Incrementality Score Into Earlier Profitability

Huckleberry Labs OG image

60%

incrementality factor uncovered with an AppsFlyer geo-lift test

110%

incremental ROAS reached much earlier in the customer lifecycle, up from 72% before the team diagnosed and improved the underlying marketing strategy
Huckleberry Labs OG image

Overview

  • Trusted by over 6 million families, Huckleberry is the No. 1 baby tracker app. 
  • Huckleberry helps parents understand their child’s sleep and find a path to better rest.
  • They combine pediatric sleep expertise with AI to create personalized sleep plans tailored to each family’s unique needs.

Background

Growth for Huckleberry Labs comes from a mix of paid acquisition on Meta and strong organic demand. Heading into 2026, the team had set an ambitious double-digit growth target. Huckleberry Labs already measured performance with AppsFlyer for attribution and Amplitude for product analytics, giving it a clear view of how new users behaved after they installed the app.

Challenge

In April 2026, Huckleberry Labs’ organic acquisition encountered new headwinds. Google’s AI Overviews were eating into the blog-driven traffic that normally fed the top of the funnel. Erich Detert, Huckleberry Labs’ Director of Performance Marketing, and his team did what most performance marketers would do: they ramped up Meta spend in May to close the gap.

Meta-attributed installs climbed, but the returns started to soften, and that left a question Erich couldn’t shake: how much of that Meta spend was buying customers who would have found Huckleberry Labs anyway, ad or no ad? 

“We didn’t want Meta grading its own paper. Having a third party like AppsFlyer measure incrementality was extremely important to us.”

Erich Detert
Erich Detert
Director of Performance Marketing, Huckleberry

Solution

The geo-lift test in AppsFlyer came back at 60% incrementality, meaning 40% of Meta-attributed conversions would have happened without the ad spend. The easy, instinctive move with a number like that is to cut the budget and chase a higher-performing channel.

“If a campaign was only 30% incremental, your immediate reaction would be: I’m going to move the budget to other channels. But what if the campaign is not incremental for different reasons? What if the creative is wrong? What if budgeting is wrong? What if there are targeting issues?”

Eran Dunsky
Eran Dunsky
Head of Product, AppsFlyer North America

Erich and team treated the incrementality score as a starting point for diagnosis, not a trigger to pull the plug. Erich connected Claude to AppsFlyer and Amplitude through MCP, the integration layer behind AppsFlyer’s Agentic AI Suite, and threw in a third ingredient: public birth-rate data.

What would normally take a dedicated analyst team weeks took an afternoon, and it surfaced three findings:

  • 61% of ad-driven new accounts came from the newborn segment, the most self-selecting, highest-intent group of users, the ones most likely to find Huckleberry Labs regardless of any ad
  • Expecting parents and parents of infants two to eleven months old were underserved by the existing creative and targeting
  • Several major metro markets were underserved relative to their birth rate per capita, an opportunity score Claude built by combining AppsFlyer account data with the CDC figures

Huckleberry Labs shifted creative and strategy toward expecting parents and parents of infants, swapping generic messaging for language and creatives tailored to each stage. The team also fed the metro opportunity scores into Meta’s bid-optimization tool, Value Rules, to bid higher in the under-indexed markets.

Results

The shift didn’t just retarget the ads; it changed the underlying economics. Parents of infants have immediate, active sleep goals, so they subscribe more quickly. Expecting parents take longer to convert but carry a higher lifetime value at the 24- to 36-month mark. Expanding into less-penetrated markets opened up additional opportunities for incremental growth. And pulling back from the newborn segment meant Huckleberry Labs stopped paying to acquire users who would have subscribed on their own anyway.

Cost per new account improved within the first two weeks and continued to improve over the following month as the audience mix shifted toward expecting parents and parents of infants. Organic acquisition recovered right alongside it, resolving the headwinds Erich had flagged at the outset.

Huckleberry Labs is now reaching profitable incremental ROAS at a point in the customer lifecycle that used to feel out of reach.

Looking ahead

The instinct when an incrementality score comes back low is to cut spend. Huckleberry Labs’ experience demonstrates that the opposite is a better strategy: treat the number as the start of an investigation, not the end of the conversation.

Incrementality isn’t a one-time measurement, either. Huckleberry Labs plans to rerun geo-lift tests on a set schedule as campaigns and markets continue to shift.

Ready to start making good choices?

Background
Ready to start making good choices?